WritersWeekly has exchanged several emails with McGraw-Hill regarding this complaint, but it seems they've just been giving us the run-around. We are publishing this after tiring of hearing them tell us they're looking into it.
We haven't heard anything from the accused author, Jan Goldberg. Another writer claims her copyright was violated when her essay was published in one of Jan Goldberg's books without permission. Jan Goldberg also did not respond to the writer.
From: Angela Hoy
Subject: COMPLAINT about McGraw-Hill / Jan Goldberg, author of Homebodies and Other Independent Souls
Date sent: Thu, 01 Mar 2007 15:20:30 -0500
Copies to: firstname.lastname@example.org
March 1, 2007
Jan Goldberg - JanGold1@aol.com
924 Long Road
Glenview, IL 60025
Lauren Lynch - email@example.com
Two Penn Plaza, 11th Floor / 12221 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10121 / New York, NY 10020-1095
WritersWeekly.com has received a complaint about:
Jan Goldberg, author of Homebodies and Other Independent Souls /
McGraw-Hill Professional / mhprofessional.com
WritersWeekly.com is a publication that publishes information for and
about freelance writers. The publication is the largest-circulation
freelance writing ezine in the world.
As part of that information, WritersWeekly.com publishes a Warnings
section on its website and in its newsletter. This warning section
contains reports about publications that are unprofessional in dealing
with writers, have refused to pay writers money owed to them, who have
not abided by their contracts, or who have unfair contract terms. These
reports are used by WritersWeekly.com's subscribers to decide which
publications they should and should not work with.
Your firm has been submitted to us for inclusion in the
WritersWeekly.com Whispers and Warnings section.
Step one of our investigation of this report is to gather all relevant
correspondence between your publication and the person submitting the
complaint so that we can piece together that person's side of the story.
Step one of our investigation has been completed.
[LZ] (name not published here but was, of course, provided to
the publisher and to Jan Goldberg) alleges you committed copyright infringement by
publishing one of her articles in your book without permission or
payment. It also appears she is being given the run-around by
McGraw Hill and that she is being ignored by Jan Goldberg.
[LZ] is requesting $500 for the unauthorized use of her
work. See complete allegation under my signature.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
The second step in our investigation is to send this communication to
your firm to get its side of the story. If you have evidence disputing
these allegations, or would like to make your own statement about these
allegations for publication in our report, please email
within two business days.
***All correspondence for our investigations must be in writing and is
subject to publication.***
If you do owe this person money, we strongly suggest you read
this article before responding:
http://www.writersweekly.com/the_latest ... 32006.html
Our report on your firm is scheduled for inclusion in our publication
If there is no response to these allegations, WritersWeekly.com will
still publish this complaint, but our readers will not be able to read
your side of the story.
We appreciate your prompt response in this matter.
While "googling" my name, I came across a McGraw Hill - Professional
book, "Homebodies and Other Independent Souls," by a Jan Goldberg. The
publication date was 2000. This book contains an article I wrote and
Once I submitted my article, I never heard another word. Thus, you can
imagine my "chagrin" when I came across this use of my article.
I don't know how many times in hardcover, softcover and varied
ebooks it has appeared without my knowledge. In fact, it occurs to
me that, since I didn't even receive the usual complimentary copy
that many authors give to folks who help them out on a story ...
she knew precisely what she was doing.
I immediately emailed an Executive Editor @ MH. He replied within hours.
This isn't his department, he said, and he asked who my first contact was
with MH. I thought I had made it obvious that I did not know who to
contact and that I hoped he could put me in the right direction.
At one point, the contact editor said the book was published by
another outfit, which McGraw Hill subsequently bought out.
Then I gave him the ISBN of new edition coming out in March.
He then referred me to the current editor of that book.
Jan Goldberg has yet to respond to my email. I put a tracer on the
email and she read it ten minutes after I sent it, but hasn't answered.
Oddly enough, the Google page on which I found all this info
(including my section in total) has disappeared! Now, isn't
that strange? I'm obviously encountering a tad of resistance here.
This is a clear-cut case of copyright infringement - unauthorized use
committed willfully and without my knowledge.